CHAPTER 5: Big River
Eight days after the Obama inauguration, and a cold rain
lashes down on Gansevoort Street. Last night there was
snow, but the thin crust it left on the cobblestone street
has turned to gray mush. Pedestrians clamber over
icy mounds at sidewalk intersections. Taxicabs race past,
unfazed by the slick conditions, splashing dirty water
onto pinstriped slacks and blue jean legs that stand too
close to the curb.
Just above Greenwich Village, Gansevoort Street cuts straight
through Manhattan’s meatpacking district on a short
but noble dash toward the Hudson River. As far as I know,
nobody has slaughtered animals here for decades, but the
massive, towering brick buildings that once held sprawling
killing floors remain, a reminder that blood-drenched
sawdust and factory whistles were once as much symbols
of New York as today’s Starbucks coffee shops, Duane
Reade drugstores, and Prada sunglasses.
Along the Gansevoort side of one of those old slaughterhouses,
dented steel doors hide various businesses. It’s
hard to tell what kind of businesses because no signs announce
their activities. An after-hours club? A storage facility?
An escort service? In contrast, across the street, commerce
carries on without embarrassment: a diner, a furniture
store, and—a bit farther up the street toward Ninth
Avenue— a trendy French eatery named Pastis. Some
know the neighborhood for its Hogs and Heifers bar, where
folks go to model their biker wear, sorority girls flash
their friends for thrills, and the likes of Julia Roberts
and Paul McCartney show up to dance on the bar.
Behind one of the steel doors is a recording studio. Naturally,
it is hidden. Nobody is invited to stop in and record a
track for his mama, like Elvis Presley did at Sun Records
in Memphis. It’s a serious studio, yet not so serious
that its lease cannot be yanked away. Skyrocketing rents—at
this point still impervious to the economic climate and
fueled by the popular nightclubs and restaurants in the
neighborhood—will spell the end of this studio, or
at least the end of its incarnation on Gansevoort Street.
Soon, it’s a pretty good guess, a shop offering foreign
coffee and baked things too pretty to eat or maybe an upscale
workout spot will take its place. A portrait of a woman
in a head covering stares out from the wall next to
the gray door, her expression seemingly oblivious to the
studio’s certain fate.
Inside, the studio buzzes with activity. Like the ubiquitous
scaffolding that despite the economy still wraps so
many buildings in Manhattan, the framework for Rosanne’s
session comes together. John Leventhal positions microphones,
clears space in the recording booth, and checks levels.
Around him, Bestor Cram’s documentary film
crew members—still hoping for funding at this stage—rush
to erect lighting, connect to the studio soundboard, white
balance their cameras, and check their own levels. They
have littered the hallway that leads from the street entrance
to the actual studio with bags and cases of equipment;
back and forth they hustle, moving cameras, tripods, and
cords. Focused, Leventhal strides to each task while the
crew hops around him. It’s like an Irish hooley.
To Leventhal, though, it is more hassle than hooley. He
rules his studio, needing more than anything to block noise
and traffic that will upset his process. But right
now, there’s nothing but noise and traffic.
He’s courteous always, helping Dominic Musacchio,
the soundman, plug into the main audio source, digging
up a cord for Jesse Beecher the cameraman. Still, occasional
sarcasm and exasperated sighs betray him. Rightly,
he fears that cameras will stiffen his actors, Rosanne
and a drummer who will be playing along with the tracks,
and that the mystery and magic of record making will disappear
when it is laid bare for viewers and readers. He will be
happy when the day’s shooting ends.
Outside in the bleak midwinter, a cab drops Rosanne in
front of the dour woman. She limps to the steel door and
pulls herself into the hallway. She lifts off an impossibly
large and furry hat and glances at the mad scene. Nestling
into a soft couch, she pulls out her iPhone (which during
breaks will be as constant in her hand as a glass of water)
and explains her limp to me. A few days before, she dropped
a boiling kettle of water, scalding her right foot. The
next evening, while performing with former husband Rodney
Crowell at Lincoln Center’s Allen Room, she tortured
her foot in the tight shoes she chose to wear. Over the
weekend, infection set in.
Will she have to recline on a couch with her microphone
and deliver “Miss the Mississippi and You,” popularized
by Jimmie Rodgers? I’m reminded that the Singing
Brakeman, struggling with tuberculosis, needed a couch
close to him while on one of his New York sessions,
and that Rosanne’s father toward the end rested on
his studio couch when the day’s work drained him.
As it is, Rosanne will forgo the Jimmie Rodgers song today
and sits only during her breaks. She takes on Patsy Cline’s “She’s
Got You” instead. John has worked out a groovy arrangement
that opens with smart electric piano riffs and rings ever
so faintly of Floyd Cramer. The Cramer connection, though,
doesn’t stick for long; Booker T. Jones poking at
Hammond B3 keys seems more like it.
Behind her mic, which sits squarely in the middle of the
room and faces John—who’s at the board as engineer—Rosanne
wraps herself around the groove, rocking toward her entrance
to the song.
One of Patsy Cline’s greatest performances, “She’s
Got You” showcased her powerful vocals like no other
when it was released in 1962 and established songwriter
Hank Cochran’s career in Nashville. Sadly, she
died in a plane crash within a year of its topping the
charts. But Cochran would go on to write a dozen classics,
including “Make the World Go Away” and “Don’t
Touch Me.” “It’s a list song,” observes
Rosanne of Cochran’s song. “I’ve got
your picture, I’ve got your records, I’ve got
your class ring. And in that way it’s kind of perfect,
kind of satisfying. The fact that it’s content mirroring
context is great, but you can kind of hear the songwriter
going, ‘What else?’ What else would she have
that he doesn’t. It’s kind of perfect, the
perfect country song.”
So a song that makes a list appears on The List. Clever.
It links to the album. But in a real way it links to Rosanne.
One of the foremost female country stars of the 1980s
recalling the undisputed country music queen of the early
1960s reveals that The List is every bit as much a search
for Rosanne Cash’s place in the music schema as it
is a tribute to her father’s sense of history. Up
in Rosanne’s attic, she had dug out for me a 1996
New York Times Magazine piece she wrote on Patsy. It was
at the height of the Patsy revival, when the Hollywood
biopic Sweet Dreams was still fresh in the public’s
consciousness and the touring stage show Always . . . Patsy
Cline was hitting the big towns. In the piece, Rosanne’s
admiration for her forebear was genuine, and it’s
clear that she understood and related to the pioneer’s
attitude. “Patsy Cline was wicked and fabulous when
both qualities meant something, before they were cheap
ideas used to market more flaccid talents. She was
a source of fascination, distrust and raw, if hidden, admiration.
But not judgment: there was nothing to attach judgment
to because she, Patsy, did not judge herself.” Later
in the essay, Rosanne’s
mother reveals to her that Patsy had visited their home
in California when Rosanne was too young to remember. “I
sighed wistfully,” she wrote. “Somewhere in
the blackout of early childhood I had had an encounter
with Patsy Cline. I may spend the rest of my life trying
to remember it.”
Rosanne also failed to remember that Patsy Cline had at
least once arrived at her home bruised and battered, and
her mother and father had given her refuge. “That
sounds really familiar,” she remarks when I
bring it up. “I remember there being something like
that, like a secret, they wouldn’t tell us kids what
was wrong. It was the same thing when they brought Carl
[Perkins], when Dad brought Carl home and he was just bottomed
out on alcohol, like a secret. ‘Don’t tell
the children what’s really wrong.’”
Like Perkins, Patsy often toured with Johnny Cash, joining
the show for stretches through southern Canada or the upper
Midwest. She followed Cash through California too, and
one night out there she’d clashed again with a male
companion and Cash had carried her home. She stayed around
for a few days until she healed. The act of hospitality
contradicts the popular perception of the Cashes’ California
household where we know Rosanne’s mother fretted
over her drifting husband and Rosanne and her sisters pined
for their dad. Indeed, there could be refuge and healing.
According to the script, Vivian should have loathed Patsy,
who came from the world that was stealing her husband away. “I
would have thought that too,” admits Rosanne. “There
was just something special about Patsy that my mother loved,
just loved her. So if my mother felt that way about it,
she could forgive anything, she could overlook it. I think
all those [resentful] feelings were reserved for June.”
In front of the microphone, Rosanne brushes back her hair
and digs in. There’s no self-consciousness. She’s
scribbled out the lyrics on a yellow pad of paper, and
with bifocals perched on her nose, she gets into the rhythm
of the list of “She’s Got You.” She will
screech to a halt when the lines elude her and curse flatness
when it creeps in from time to time. But always she returns
to battle. Lifting her scarf back up around her neck, she
tells John to start over. “Keep the first two
verses,” she demands. “But let me get this
third one.”
At times John fails to see what has dissatisfied
Rosanne when she stops, but he dutifully begins again with
her, punching up the track where she has left it and watching
her levels intently as she continues. But it cuts the other
way too. According no license to their marriage, he stops
her midline. “It’s a little shrill. Do it one
more time.” She heeds him. She will rarely protest.
Rosanne trusts John’s instincts. She lets him produce
and allows him his vision.
This dance will conclude minutes after the noon hour. “She’s
Got You” is done . . . for today.
|